
Driving in Ontario offers freedom and mobility, but for high-risk drivers, securing auto insurance can be an uphill battle. Auto insurance for high-risk drivers in Ontario is not only expensive but also challenging to find. High-risk drivers, labeled due to a history of traffic violations, accidents, or other driving infractions, often face limited options and sky-high premiums. However, understanding the nuances of high-risk auto insurance and strategically navigating the market can make the process more manageable.
This guide explores the ins and outs of auto insurance for high-risk drivers in Ontario, offering practical tips, real-life examples, and actionable advice to help you find the best coverage.
What Makes You a High-Risk Driver in Ontario?
In Ontario, drivers are categorized as high-risk due to various reasons, impacting their insurance premiums and coverage options. But what exactly qualifies someone as a high-risk driver?
Who is Considered a High-Risk Driver?
A driver may be labeled as high-risk for several reasons, including:
- Multiple Traffic Violations: Accumulating several traffic tickets for speeding, running red lights, or other infractions.
- Accidents and Claims History: A history of fault accidents or multiple insurance claims can raise red flags.
- DUI Convictions: Driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs leads to severe penalties and a high-risk classification.
- License Suspension: A suspended license due to traffic violations or legal issues.
- Young or Inexperienced Drivers: New drivers with little driving history or experience are often categorized as high-risk.
- Poor Credit Score: In some cases, a low credit score can influence insurance rates, although this is regulated in Ontario.
These factors paint a picture of a driver who statistically presents a higher likelihood of filing an insurance claim. Insurance companies in Ontario assess risk levels based on driving records, accident history, and other variables to determine premiums and coverage options.

Why is Auto Insurance Expensive for High-Risk Drivers?
Auto insurance for high-risk drivers in Ontario is notoriously expensive. But why?
Risk Assessment and Premium Calculation
Insurance companies use complex algorithms to evaluate the risk of insuring a driver. For high-risk drivers, the probability of filing a claim is significantly higher. Therefore, insurers charge higher premiums to mitigate potential losses.
Factors Affecting High-Risk Auto Insurance Premiums
- Driving Record: A history of accidents, traffic violations, or DUI convictions increases premiums.
- Age and Experience: Young drivers or those with less driving experience are considered riskier.
- Vehicle Type: High-performance or luxury vehicles come with higher insurance costs.
- Location: Urban areas with high traffic density or crime rates lead to increased premiums.
- Coverage Level: Comprehensive coverage and additional riders elevate the premium amount.
- Continuous Coverage History: Gaps in insurance coverage can lead to higher rates.
These elements combine to determine the overall cost, making it essential for high-risk drivers to shop around and compare quotes from different insurers.
How to Find Auto Insurance for High-Risk Drivers in Ontario
Finding affordable auto insurance as a high-risk driver in Ontario can be daunting, but it’s not impossible. Here are some effective strategies:
1. Shop Around and Compare Quotes
Different insurers assess risk factors differently. Comparing multiple quotes from various providers can help you find the most affordable option.
2. Work with High-Risk Insurance Brokers
High-risk insurance brokers specialize in finding policies tailored for high-risk drivers. Some of the top brokers in Ontario include:
- Insurance Hero – Known for competitive rates for high-risk drivers.
- Regal Insurance – Offers customized solutions for non-standard auto insurance.
- Duliban Insurance Brokers – Specializes in high-risk auto insurance coverage.
- McDougall Insurance – Provides flexible payment options and comprehensive coverage.
- Sharp Insurance – Tailors policies to meet unique high-risk needs.
3. Consider Facility Association Insurance
Facility Association is a last-resort insurance pool for drivers who cannot secure insurance through regular providers. Although premiums are typically higher, it’s a viable option for those struggling to find coverage elsewhere.
4. Opt for Non-Standard Auto Insurance
Non-standard auto insurance caters to high-risk drivers by offering basic liability coverage at competitive rates. This type of insurance may have fewer frills but provides the mandatory coverage required by law.
5. Defensive Driving Courses
Taking a defensive driving course can demonstrate responsibility and reduce insurance premiums. Many insurers offer discounts for drivers who have completed certified courses.
6. Improve Your Driving Record
- Obey Traffic Laws: Avoid tickets for speeding, running red lights, or other violations.
- Practice Safe Driving Habits: Defensive driving techniques can help maintain a clean driving record.
- Accident Forgiveness: Some insurers offer accident forgiveness programs, protecting your premium from increasing after your first at-fault accident.
Best High-Risk Auto Insurance Companies in Ontario
While mainstream insurance companies may avoid high-risk drivers, specialized insurers cater to this segment. Here are some of the best:
1. Coachman Insurance
- Specializes in high-risk auto insurance.
- Offers competitive rates and flexible payment options.
- Known for its customer-centric approach and comprehensive coverage.
2. Facility Association
- An insurance pool for high-risk drivers unable to secure conventional insurance.
- Provides mandatory coverage but at a higher cost.
- Ideal as a last-resort option.
3. Pafco Insurance
- Tailors policies for drivers with poor driving records or license suspensions.
- Offers non-standard auto insurance at reasonable rates.
4. Economical Insurance
- Provides flexible policies with optional add-ons like accident forgiveness.
- Known for good customer service and reliable claims processing.
5. Intact Insurance
- Offers tailored solutions for high-risk drivers.
- Discounts available for bundling with other insurance policies.

Tips to Lower High-Risk Auto Insurance Premiums
While high-risk auto insurance is generally expensive, the following strategies can help reduce premiums:
1. Increase Deductibles
Choosing a higher deductible reduces monthly premiums. However, ensure you can afford the out-of-pocket expense in case of a claim.
2. Bundle Insurance Policies
Bundling auto insurance with home or life insurance can lead to significant discounts.
3. Install Safety Features
Equipping your vehicle with safety features like anti-theft devices, backup cameras, or advanced safety equipment reduces risk and lowers premiums.
4. Maintain Continuous Coverage
Gaps in insurance coverage can increase rates. Ensure uninterrupted coverage to avoid penalties.
5. Pay Annually Instead of Monthly
Paying the annual premium upfront often results in a discount compared to monthly installments.
Related FAQs
1. What is high-risk auto insurance?
High-risk auto insurance is coverage designed for drivers with poor driving records, DUI convictions, or multiple traffic violations.
2. Who qualifies as a high-risk driver in Ontario?
Drivers with multiple traffic violations, fault accidents, DUI convictions, or young and inexperienced drivers are considered high-risk.
3. Can I lower my high-risk auto insurance premium?
Yes, by maintaining a clean driving record, taking defensive driving courses, and choosing higher deductibles.
4. Which companies offer the best high-risk auto insurance in Ontario?
Coachman Insurance, Pafco Insurance, and Facility Association are top providers.
5. Can a defensive driving course reduce my premium?
Yes, certified defensive driving courses can lead to discounts with many insurers.
Conclusion
Navigating the world of auto insurance for high-risk drivers in Ontario is challenging but achievable with the right strategies. From understanding what makes a driver high-risk to exploring the best insurance companies and cost-saving tips, informed decisions can make a substantial difference.
By maintaining a clean driving record, leveraging defensive driving courses, and working with specialized high-risk insurance brokers, high-risk drivers can find suitable coverage at reasonable rates. Auto insurance for high-risk drivers in Ontario doesn’t have to be an insurmountable hurdle—it just requires knowledge, patience, and strategic planning.
How Ontario Insurance Can Help with High-Risk Auto Insurance
At Ontario Insurance, we understand the challenges high-risk drivers face when searching for auto insurance. Our team specializes in finding affordable coverage tailored to your needs, regardless of your driving history. Let us help you get back on the road with confidence.